01_Tahrir Model, Tahrir Square, Cairo 2011, Credit Themba Lewis.jpg

Original Tahrir Square Model in Tahrir Square, Cairo, Egypt. February 2011, Credit: Themba Lewis.

THE IMAGE OF THE SQUARE: Redefining Citizenship by Design

By Samaa Elimam

ABSTRACT

THE IMAGE OF THE SQUARE: Redefining Citizenship by Design

A spirited protester building a miniature model of Tahrir Square, as he occupies the space, is testament to the performative power of a singular spatial practice. Such public actions that incite global ramifications, as well as their associated imagery, establish a rare capacity to mobilize towards a collective design project. Amidst our contemporary rapid and connected modes of spatial production, moments like these question routine spatial practices and perceptions, instigating a critical reassessment of our social spaces. These forms of public action, and the way we chose to represent and reproduce them, are critical to distinguish a rare and true legibility that has the potential to drive new paradigms of design, as well as citizenship.

In the case of pre-2011 Cairo, streetscapes have always been at the root of everyday urban existence, with sidewalks and corners that demonstrate various degrees of citizen claim to the city, often manifesting into spatial conflicts. Spatial practices in the city have constantly displayed a disparity between formal and informal, particularly in dense central areas like Cairo’s downtown. During the events of 2011, the shift from the space of the street to the square was the self-assembling of these smaller informal practices, proclaimed at an entirely new scale. This swelling up may be attributed to the square’s visibility, a space perhaps that – being inhabited for the first time – permitted new, untold lines of sight and subsequent visual connections. To the international community, the images and media that circulated were the results of a direct, coherent narrative. To Egypt, it was merely the first, and still nascent, step towards a true self-comprehension of society’s pluralities.

In The Image of the City, Kevin Lynch identifies legibility as a new measure of urban assessment vis à vis the city’s physical, but more importantly, cognitive image. Using this criterion to make sense of the events in this context, this paper argues that beyond the overused aerial image – the totalizing view from above that denotes a longing for legibility – forms of representation should seek to break down the inherent socio-political pluralities and complexities. The image, as well as the act of creating and reproducing it, is the instrument through which designers understand and reconstruct the world. Therefore, to move beyond the sort of pseudo-legibility that has come to represent the “icon” of Tahrir Square, is to move towards a space where design has the agency to transform spatial practice.

The paper concludes with initiatives that – rather than accepting the sweeping images as a sort of go-to proof-of-revolution – strive towards representational techniques that enrich our conception of the multiple socio-economic dimensions inherent in a city in flux. Furthermore, they bring together community groups, architects, urban planners, historians, and artists to engage in a critical discourse towards a collective design agenda. In this way, they begin to redefine the design process, in essence, as a public act. These participatory and projective forms of representation will define not only the new paradigm for design, but also for what it means to inhabit the city.

 

OUTLINE

THE IMAGE OF THE SQUARE: Redefining Citizenship by Design

 

I. Introduction: A Nested Square

II. From the Streets to the Square, the Right to the City

III. A Quest for Legibility and the Aerial Image

IV. The Agency of Design

V. A Space of Dialogue and Alternative Representations

VI. Conclusion: Towards a True Legibility - New Paradigm for Design, New Paradigm for Citizenship

02_Re-imagined Model, Radcliffe 2012, Credit Samaa Elimam.jpg

Re-Imagined Tahrir Model at Byerly Gallery, Radcliffe Institute, Cambridge, MA. March 2012, Credit: Samaa Elimam.

03_Egyptian Activists Plan, Translated, p. 4.jpg

Excerpt, p. 4. "Egyptian Activists Plan." Translated. February 2011.

04_Egyptian Activists Plan, Translated, p. 10.jpg

Excerpt, p. 10. "Egyptian Activists Plan." Translated. February 2011.

05_Archiving the City in Flux, pp. 32-33, Credit Omar Nagati.jpg

Excerpt, pp 32-33. Archiving the City in Flux. Credit: Omar Nagati.

06_Archiving the City in Flux, pp. 24-25, Credit Omar Nagati.jpg

Excerpt, pp 24-25. Archiving the City in Flux. Credit: Omar Nagati.

07_Breakdown of Model Components, Credit Samaa Elimam.jpg

Breakdown of Model Components. Credit: Samaa Elimam

BRACKET [takes action]

Housing Resistant Forms of Life

Housing Resistant Forms of Life

By Hamed Khosravi
Shared Grammars, Individual Desires: Participatory Planning and Slum Upgrading in Brazil

Shared Grammars, Individual Desires: Participatory Planning and Slum Upgrading in Brazil

By Gabriel Duarte
Open House

Open House

By Matthew Mazzotta
Mobile Loitering: public infrastructure for a highly gendered urban context

Mobile Loitering: public infrastructure for a highly gendered urban context

By Mariam Kamara, Elizabeth Golden
The Space of the Commons: Dheisheh Refugee Camp

The Space of the Commons: Dheisheh Refugee Camp

By Alison Hugill, Dan Dorocic
See that my grave is kept clean: ritual continuity & spatial resistance along Futenma's inverted periphery

See that my grave is kept clean: ritual continuity & spatial resistance along Futenma's inverted periphery

By Steven Chodoriwsky
A Subject of Action

A Subject of Action

By Albert Pope
Place de la Republique in Paris

Place de la Republique in Paris

By TVK - Trévelo & Viger-Kohler Architectes Urbanistes
Delirious actions: gender tactics in public space

Delirious actions: gender tactics in public space

By Serafina Amoroso

ELASTIC COMMEMORATION

ELASTIC COMMEMORATION

By Guy Königstein
BREAKING INTO THE CITY Urban explorers' architectural posture

BREAKING INTO THE CITY Urban explorers' architectural posture

By Michael Cook
Off the Wall

Off the Wall

By Katherine Jenkins, Parker Sutton
Cultivate Collective

Cultivate Collective

By De Peter Yi
FAS: Architectural Activism

FAS: Architectural Activism

By FAS- Foreign Architects Switzerland
What a body can do: the political as generator of a common spatiality

What a body can do: the political as generator of a common spatiality

By Lucia Jalon Oyarzun
Bronx is Up, WTC is down: paraphrasing Leonard Bernstein. A public service guerilla action for Architecture League’s Make a Difference in Two Days

Bronx is Up, WTC is down: paraphrasing Leonard Bernstein. A public service guerilla action for Architecture League’s Make a Difference in Two Days

By Austin+Mergold With James Bowman, Denise Ramzy, Sally Reynolds
Contested Energies

Contested Energies

By Stephen Mueller, Ersela Kripa
Spaces of Conflict

Spaces of Conflict

By Lori A. Brown
The Empty City

The Empty City

By Martin Sztyk
SLANTED MEMORIAL

SLANTED MEMORIAL

By Jin Young Song
Next page » Loading