Spaces of Conflict
By Lori A. Brown
A related series of questions one may ask include what is the value of design thinking for the greater public in terms of abortion and public space? What role could architects have in exploring overlooked spaces like abortion clinics and engaging in their design and security? How can design positively impact access? Although not explicitly aligned with the types of non-places theorized by the anthropologist Marc Augé, reproductive healthcare facilities have a certain affinity coinciding with what as he states “[n]on-places could be seen, approaching them from another vantage point, as the heirs to everything that has created discomfort or annoyance in the history of human spaces.”[iii] Although the spaces of abortion are not the creator of discomfort, the idea of these spaces and what they represent definitely fall within this categorization and the physicality of their existences clearly create discomfort for a large segment of the population.
One of the initial issues that drew me to this research was the intersection of a highly politicized and charged space being contested out in the public realm. Public space is critical in different ways for abortion clinics. Anti-choice protestors regularly exercise their first amendment freedoms by protesting out in front of abortion clinics across the United States. This right is part of the freedom individual citizens of this country have to publicly speak out against issues one is against and anti-choice protestors are protected under law to be able to do so. State and federal courts have ruled both in support and in opposition to certain abortion rights cases weighing free speech against abortion access. This has produced a variety of legislation differing dramatically from state-to-state controlling and manipulating the actual geography and physical boundaries around clinic properties, buildings and people’s bodies.[iv] This remains ongoing and just this past January 2014 the Supreme Court heard arguments challenging the constitutionality of the 35’ buffer zones around abortion clinics in the state of Massachusetts.[v]
[i] This essay is part of a larger research project recently published in Contested Bodies: Abortion Clinics, Women’s Shelters and Hospitals (Ashgate 2013).
[ii] “The United States Constitution.” (n.d.).
[iii] On the Move 2012.
[iv] Madsen v. Women’s Health Center (1994) upheld noise restrictions during certain times of certain days. The FACE law (1994) protects anyone exercising their right to reproductive services and First Amendment religious freedoms and makes unlawful to intentionally damage or destroy facility property or places of worship. Schenck v. Pro-Choice Network of Western New York (1997) upheld a 15-foot fixed zone around doorways and doorway entrances, parking lots entrances, driveways and driveway entrance of the clinic facilities. Hill v. Colorado (2000) upheld 100-feet fixed zone around health care facilities and 8 feet bubble zone around someone entering and exiting a clinic.
[v] See Valencia 2014, Barnes 2014, Mauro 2014 and Totenberg 2014 for coverage on this case.
2. Role of public space in research
a. discussion of some political theory literature including Jurgen Habermas, Nancy Fraser and Iris Marion Young
b. the public / private dichotomy and why this is problematic
c. how abortion clinics intersect within public space; where can agency be legible
d. role of the body, especially reproductive body, within public realm
3. spaces of possibility
a. role of design within build environment
b. Elizabeth Grosz asking how to think architecture differently – how do spaces of abortion provoke different possibilities?
4. case study: Kentucky (with mapping)
a. geography of access
b. state restrictions and spatial implications
c. alternatives to access: hospitals and pharmacies
d. cultural influences
26 Comments – Login to comment
judeelliot · Jan 22, 19 2:36 amThe fact that the present morphology may not be actually same as the first ground breaking strategy, numerous urban spaces and foundations stay as confirmations of communist urban planning. What's more, curiously enough, these are urban elements that have real conflict with market-situated economy, assignment help service and right now, the morphology of the city is already changing.
abdulkaleem · Mar 13, 19 7:11 am
That's a piece of excellent news after the good researching and I hope peoples will take it useful points from this post and also take more info with online assignment writing service about the Spaces of Conflict because some of the peoples do not properly understand these type of subjects.
Tyson24 · Apr 10, 19 2:18 amNice
jasonjames · Jun 27, 19 9:01 am
After so much research I found something good and interesting. I got a great lesson from this article and something good for my site best assistance in UK. In this article very well, women's rights, great information about politics have been given.
jessicawatson · Jul 8, 19 6:10 amHi there. The professionals from this writing service are willing to work even with the most challenging topics. Therefore ask them for help https://300writers.com/definition-essay-topics.html if you are in difficult situations.
lucasaiden · Jul 19, 19 5:49 amUbergizmo
christopherhardy1 · Nov 30, 19 6:47 amLooking for someone who can Take My Classes Online For Me? We're here to provide professional online help for class assignments, homework, exams & tasks.
biocoredripbar · Apr 24, 20 10:02 am
Essaytigers is the professional essay writing service in London many student used to take assignment help. Essaytigers have the most professional assignment writers.we provides best services.
lisa86885332 · May 2, 20 12:58 amThanks for this! I live in Tacoma Washington and this will be super helpful for my website https://www.tacomahousepainter.com
adamsmith11 · May 3, 20 6:32 pmWe are a Quality Renovation Contractor that Renews and Brings Life back to Existing Properties no Matter what kind of Space you are looking to Renovate: Bathrooms, Living Rooms, Kitchens, or Other Living Spaces.
lindalawson · May 27, 20 10:34 am
lindalawson · May 27, 20 10:34 am
carolinaromanova · Jun 28, 20 11:41 amToday, there are zillions of best popular music our experts are around with as well as if you want to listen up every thing or even wishes to possess a great compilation, merely concentrate on the right and also great source for internet streaming or opt for the download area for quick download. Regardless of what sort of songs you love to listen closely or what exactly you desire, whatever your preference is. Website https://watchmenmusic.com/
florahmelda · Jul 3, 20 2:17 am
English literature assignment writing services are essential for english literature coursework writing service students and English Literature Writing Services seekers.
courtmarriage · Sep 24, 20 7:08 am
lindatyler · Oct 13, 20 2:15 pmThank you for sharing such timely advice for many students. After all, communication skills are very important in modern society. I want to improve some qualities, so I use the services https://essaysservice.com/excel-expert-tips-and-tricks.html
localco · Oct 29, 20 10:26 am
And here is why, let me break it down for you. This urban street café and barbershop (yes, I said barbershop) offers a modern design with an industrial twist giving you a Scandinavian style to sit, sip, and chill at best cafe abu dhabi with best barber in abu dhabi.
electraabudhabi · Oct 29, 20 12:14 pm
Our manufacturers and suppliers are known for their quality, creativity, and technical excellence in home automation dubai We have a track record of advising, supplying, and serving esteemed organizations in the region. We have the ability to meet the highest and most stringent standards available.
colorunico · Jan 21, 21 1:44 am
Thank you, relax with unicorn coloring pages
lindalawson · Feb 3, 21 2:29 pm
iyazkhan · Feb 22, 21 1:53 amAccording to the research of Buy Essay Online UK experts, one of the major causes of conflict is the unfair distribution of wealth in the society. If you really want to overcome this, you have to take this issue seriously.
muhammadqaisarmehmood1 · Mar 20, 21 4:31 amhttps://www.prescientist.org/forums/topic/your-most-pressing-professional-locksmith-questions-answer...https://www.maroonbooks.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7587278-how-can-you-advantage-from-professional-...=https://my.quincy.edu/ICS/Campus_Life/Campus_Groups/Chalk_Hawks/Discussion.jnz?portlet=Forums&screen...https://pridenet.springfield.edu/ICS/Campus_Life/Campus_Groups/WSCB_899/Discussion.jnz?portlet=Forum...https://tiger.voorhees.edu/ICS/Campus_Life/Campus_Groups/Campus_Actitvities/Discussion.jnz?portlet=F...
muhammadqaisarmehmood1 · Mar 20, 21 4:34 amhttps://humongousstudentjellyfish.tumblr.com/post/644076676803903488/professional-automotive-locksmi...https://gumroad.com/qaisarmehmood/p/top-lock-locksmiths-and-security-is-a-full-service-locksmith-com...https://www.prescientist.org/forums/topic/your-most-pressing-professional-locksmith-questions-answer...https://www.maroonbooks.com/apps/forums/topics/show/7587278-how-can-you-advantage-from-professional-...=https://my.quincy.edu/ICS/Campus_Life/Campus_Groups/Chalk_Hawks/Discussion.jnz?portlet=Forums&screen...https://pridenet.springfield.edu/ICS/Campus_Life/Campus_Groups/WSCB_899/Discussion.jnz?portlet=Forum...https://tiger.voorhees.edu/ICS/Campus_Life/Campus_Groups/Campus_Actitvities/Discussion.jnz?portlet=F...
muhammadqaisarmehmood1 · Mar 20, 21 4:36 am
johnlead · Apr 8, 21 11:16 pmAmazing insight you have on this. I’m glad that you shared this helpful info with us. Thanks! https://www.newcastletilers.com.au/
alinaoprea · Apr 27, 21 7:39 amYou are busy with your life activities and thinking about pay someone to take my online class for me and cannot handle the online class or exam which is scheduled up? You want someone to get an A for you in your complete online course? No worry! We have come to a place where our experts always do the job with perfection. Your satisfaction is our ultimate goal.
Shared Grammars, Individual Desires: Participatory Planning and Slum Upgrading in Brazil
By Gabriel Duarte
Mobile Loitering: public infrastructure for a highly gendered urban context
By Mariam Kamara, Elizabeth Golden
See that my grave is kept clean: ritual continuity & spatial resistance along Futenma's inverted periphery
By Steven Chodoriwsky
Bronx is Up, WTC is down: paraphrasing Leonard Bernstein. A public service guerilla action for Architecture League’s Make a Difference in Two Days
By Austin+Mergold With James Bowman, Denise Ramzy, Sally Reynolds