Line of Buffer zone, Pittsburgh, PA
Spaces of Conflict
By Lori A. Brown
A related series of questions one may ask include what is the value of design thinking for the greater public in terms of abortion and public space? What role could architects have in exploring overlooked spaces like abortion clinics and engaging in their design and security? How can design positively impact access? Although not explicitly aligned with the types of non-places theorized by the anthropologist Marc Augé, reproductive healthcare facilities have a certain affinity coinciding with what as he states “[n]on-places could be seen, approaching them from another vantage point, as the heirs to everything that has created discomfort or annoyance in the history of human spaces.”[iii] Although the spaces of abortion are not the creator of discomfort, the idea of these spaces and what they represent definitely fall within this categorization and the physicality of their existences clearly create discomfort for a large segment of the population.
One of the initial issues that drew me to this research was the intersection of a highly politicized and charged space being contested out in the public realm. Public space is critical in different ways for abortion clinics. Anti-choice protestors regularly exercise their first amendment freedoms by protesting out in front of abortion clinics across the United States. This right is part of the freedom individual citizens of this country have to publicly speak out against issues one is against and anti-choice protestors are protected under law to be able to do so. State and federal courts have ruled both in support and in opposition to certain abortion rights cases weighing free speech against abortion access. This has produced a variety of legislation differing dramatically from state-to-state controlling and manipulating the actual geography and physical boundaries around clinic properties, buildings and people’s bodies.[iv] This remains ongoing and just this past January 2014 the Supreme Court heard arguments challenging the constitutionality of the 35’ buffer zones around abortion clinics in the state of Massachusetts.[v]
[i] This essay is part of a larger research project recently published in Contested Bodies: Abortion Clinics, Women’s Shelters and Hospitals (Ashgate 2013).
[ii] “The United States Constitution.” (n.d.).
[iii] On the Move 2012.
[iv] Madsen v. Women’s Health Center (1994) upheld noise restrictions during certain times of certain days. The FACE law (1994) protects anyone exercising their right to reproductive services and First Amendment religious freedoms and makes unlawful to intentionally damage or destroy facility property or places of worship. Schenck v. Pro-Choice Network of Western New York (1997) upheld a 15-foot fixed zone around doorways and doorway entrances, parking lots entrances, driveways and driveway entrance of the clinic facilities. Hill v. Colorado (2000) upheld 100-feet fixed zone around health care facilities and 8 feet bubble zone around someone entering and exiting a clinic.
[v] See Valencia 2014, Barnes 2014, Mauro 2014 and Totenberg 2014 for coverage on this case.
Outline:
1. Intro
2. Role of public space in research
a. discussion of some political theory literature including Jurgen Habermas, Nancy Fraser and Iris Marion Young
b. the public / private dichotomy and why this is problematic
c. how abortion clinics intersect within public space; where can agency be legible
d. role of the body, especially reproductive body, within public realm
3. spaces of possibility
a. role of design within build environment
b. Elizabeth Grosz asking how to think architecture differently – how do spaces of abortion provoke different possibilities?
4. case study: Kentucky (with mapping)
a. geography of access
b. state restrictions and spatial implications
c. alternatives to access: hospitals and pharmacies
d. cultural influences
5. conclusion
247 Comments – Login to comment
bushrabatool · Feb 10, 25 12:48 pm
Their website development services ensure dental clinics have a professional and user-friendly online presence. best dental adsbushrabatool · Feb 12, 25 4:52 am
Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks Natural Mounjarobushrabatool · Feb 12, 25 4:07 pm
Heel erg bedankt.Geweldig! Het klinkt goed. Bedankt voor het delen..Bedankt voor het delen van de info, ga zo door met het goede werk.... Ik heb echt genoten van het verkennen van je site. goede bron... cadeaupakketbushrabatool · Feb 14, 25 9:18 am
Thanks for your information, it was really very helpfull.. Salt Tricksendwish · Feb 18, 25 5:58 am
Free ecards birthday are a timeless way to show someone you're thinking of them on their special day. Have you picked yours yet?
bushrabatool · Feb 19, 25 4:24 am
The team at New York Traffic Ticket Lawyers fights for clients' rights, helping them avoid high fines, insurance increases, and license suspensions. Court representation for traffic offenses in Bronxbushrabatool · Feb 20, 25 9:19 am
Turn any event into a magical experience with Inflatable Party Magic’s amazing bounce house rentals and party services. DFW Bounce House and Party Rentalsbushrabatool · Mar 8, 25 7:26 pm
Searching for the best UK investment platforms? The Investors Centre offers in-depth comparisons and expert guidance for investors of all levels. best crypto exchanges UKbushrabatool · Mar 12, 25 1:36 pm
Join Legiit today and access top-rated freelancers offering SEO, branding, and other digital marketing services. video SEO companybushrabatool · Mar 18, 25 3:18 pm
For safe and exciting party fun, choose Bounce Genie Tampa! Their bounce houses, water slides, and party rentals turn any occasion into a blast. Bounce Genie rentals in Tampabushrabatool · Mar 18, 25 5:15 pm
Looking for expert pressure washing in Tampa? Tampa Pressure Washing LLC ensures your home or business stays clean and well-maintained with top-tier service. Top roof cleaning services in Tampajosedaniel1 · Mar 20, 25 12:54 am
Need to write a programming paper but don’t know where to start? Our experts provide top-quality assistance in coding concepts, algorithms, software development, and more! Whether it's research, technical writing, or project documentation, we ensure well-structured, plagiarism-free, and professionally written programming papers to boost your grades. Get expert help today!
sxtpcnnhàmáy · Mar 22, 25 12:51 pm
Many businesses choose to process powdered milk but do not carefully check the factory's GMP standards, leading to poor quality products, difficult to register for circulation, and even being recalled. A GMP-standard factory not only ensures a closed production line and strict quality control, but also helps businesses develop in the long term. If you are researching this field, this article will help you understand why you should choose a GMP-standard factory: https://chietxuatduoclieu.com/tai-sao-nen-chon-nha-may-gia-cong-sua-bot-dat-chuan-gmpsxtpcnnhàmáy · Mar 22, 25 12:53 pm
Powdered milk and nut milk are becoming increasingly popular in Vietnam, not only with children but also with adults, especially customers who care about health and nutrition. But how is this market developing, what should businesses pay attention to? This article provides a detailed analysis of market share, potential, business opportunities and consumer trends. If you are in business or interested in this industry, don't miss: https://chietxuatduoclieu.com/phan-tich-thi-truong-sua-bot-sua-hat-tai-viet-namsxtpcnnhàmáy · Mar 22, 25 12:54 pm
Powdered milk is not only for children but also has many product lines for adults, the elderly, people on a diet or need special nutritional supplements. But between whole milk powder, skim milk powder, formula milk and nut milk, which is the right choice? This article analyzes in detail the popular types of powdered milk today, helping you easily make the right decision! See now: https://chietxuatduoclieu.com/cac-loai-sua-bot-pho-bien-tren-thi-truong-hien-naysxtpcnnhàmáy · Mar 22, 25 1:18 pm
Many people wonder why the same type of medicinal extract is effective in some places, but in others it is not effective. The secret lies in the source of the raw materials, the extraction process and the way of use. Some types of extract are produced according to the standards of maximum active ingredient extraction, while others are just crude, impure extracts. If you are using medicinal extract but have not seen any results, read this article immediately to find out the real reason: https://chietxuatduoclieu.com/tai-sao-cung-mot-loai-cao-duoc-lieu-nhung-cong-dung-lai-khac-nhau-he-l...sxtpcnnhàmáy · Mar 22, 25 1:19 pm
Nowadays, health care products are gradually switching to using herbal extracts thanks to their ability to retain the essence of active ingredients, helping the body absorb better. Major brands have applied herbal extracts to functional foods, cosmetics, nutritional drinks... but not everyone clearly understands their true uses. If you are learning about the role of herbal extracts in health care, this article will provide very useful information: https://chietxuatduoclieu.com/ung-dung-cao-duoc-lieu-trong-san-pham-cham-soc-suc-khoebushrabatool · Mar 23, 25 3:04 pm
This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It is the old what goes around comes around routine. gratis velkomstbonus uden indbetalingbushrabatool · Mar 27, 25 1:13 pm
Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article. Thank you so much. dmt cartbushrabatool · Mar 27, 25 9:23 pm
Thank you for the update, very nice site.. dmt cart for salebushrabatool · Mar 28, 25 6:13 pm
Great service, friendly staff, and expert grooming skills! This is my go-to place for keeping my pup looking fresh. Visit Dog is Mobile Groomingbushrabatool · Apr 1, 25 4:42 am
This grooming salon is amazing! They treat every dog like their own and provide excellent, high-quality services. My pup looks fantastic! Official Mobile Pets Grooming Cooper Citybushrabatool · Apr 24, 25 7:27 pm
They weren’t kidding about it being a ‘gacor’ site. I’ve been on a lucky streak ever since I signed up with Mamboslot! Situs Slot Gacorbushrabatool · May 7, 25 5:43 pm
Wonderful article, thanks for putting this together! This is obviously one great post. Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here. alexistotoalokchaudhary · May 8, 25 2:02 am
Well-written and informative. The neutral tone and comprehensive coverage of the topic make it a great resource. Thanks for sharing such a well-rounded perspective. Online">https://ziyyara.com/online-tuition-for-hindi">Online tuition for hindibushrabatool · May 13, 25 6:31 am
It was wondering if I could use this write-up on my other website, I will link it back to your website though.Great Thanks. https://convergentbsi.org/aliraza1111111111 · May 14, 25 5:42 am
Promotional pencil cases are a functional and stylish way to keep your brand visible. Perfect for schools, conferences, or corporate events, they help organize stationery while displaying your logo. Customizable and compact, these cases offer long-lasting exposure, making them ideal for both students and professionals. Whether given as a giveaway or included in a welcome kit, they ensure your brand stays front and center in everyday settings, offering practical value. https://www.gopromotional.co.uk/branded-products/pencil-cases
alokchaudhary · May 16, 25 3:30 am
I read your blog it's very nice and very helpful, I learn something new every time from this website, Thanks for sharing this information with us. pyp">https://ziyyara.com/ib-pyp-tuition">pyp online coursesbushrabatool · May 21, 25 12:08 pm
Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks bandar togelbushrabatool · May 22, 25 2:44 pm
i read a lot of stuff and i found that the way of writing to clearifing that exactly want to say was very good so i am impressed and ilike to come again in future.. togel totobushrabatool · May 26, 25 4:04 pm
thank you for a great post. situs togel resmibushrabatool · May 28, 25 2:11 pm
Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article. Thank you so much. Pragmatic demo
adamscott111 · May 30, 25 4:03 am
<a href="https://www.amazon.com.au/">Amazon</a>
[url=https://www.amazon.com.au/]Amazon[/url]
[Amazon](https://www.amazon.com.au/)
adamscott111 · May 30, 25 4:06 am
This is a deeply thought-provoking exploration of how architecture, public space, and reproductive rights intersect. The idea that abortion clinics function as politicized spaces—shaped not only by law but also by cultural and spatial dynamics—raises critical questions about design, access, and agency. The inclusion of thinkers like Nancy Fraser and Elizabeth Grosz brings a rich theoretical layer that helps frame these contested environments. Discussions like these can also inspire interdisciplinary perspectives, something that resonates with broader academic approaches such as those explored in Assignment Help Canberra, where spatial politics and social justice topics often intersect in research and case studies.visit: https://www.nativeassignmenthelp.com/assignment-help-canberra
bushrabatool · May 30, 25 1:43 pm
Love to read it,Waiting For More new Update and I Already Read your Recent Post its Great Thanks. situs togelhummokhan · Jun 2, 25 6:45 am
Your ultimate source for premium cannabis seeds is here! Get Seeds Right Here delivers exceptional genetics, ensuring healthy plants and abundant yields. Grow smarter, grow stronger, grow with us. marijuana clones for salebushrabatool · Jun 3, 25 5:18 pm
Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article. Thank you so much. situs slot88
aliraza1111111111 · Jun 4, 25 12:58 pm
Locksmith in Rotherham understands that spaces of conflict require both security and sensitivity. Whether it’s securing homes, businesses, or community areas, effective locksmith services help create safer environments. By installing reliable locks and access controls, they reduce risks and protect people’s peace of mind. In tense or challenging spaces, professional locksmiths play a crucial role in preventing unauthorized access and supporting conflict resolution through enhanced security measures. https://lockandkeyrotherham.co.uk/
bushrabatool · Jun 7, 25 12:59 pm
Great! It sounds good. Thanks for sharing.. togel onlinebushrabatool · Jun 12, 25 10:58 am
This is very educational content and written well for a change. It's nice to see that some people still understand how to write a quality post! alexistogelbushrabatool · Jun 14, 25 5:41 am
Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. Tentotohummokhan · Jun 15, 25 5:53 am
Thanks for your information, it was really very helpfull.. Tentoto Bandar Togelhummokhan · Jun 16, 25 7:21 am
Thanks for the post and great tips..even I also think that hard work is the most important aspect of getting success.. Situs Bandar Togelhummokhan · Jun 19, 25 5:08 am
i love reading this article so beautiful!!great job! Tentotohummokhan · Jun 24, 25 6:41 am
If you have a traffic ticket in the Bronx, you need Traffic Lawyers Bronx. They handled everything efficiently, allowing me to avoid court appearances and saving me valuable time. A truly convenient and effective service. Experienced Attorneys for Traffic Infractions in the Bronxbushrabatool · Jun 29, 25 5:13 pm
Your blog provided us with valuable information to work with. Each & every tips of your post are awesome. Thanks a lot for sharing. Keep blogging, Agen Togelbushrabatool · Jun 30, 25 5:32 pm
I found your this post while searching for some related information on blog search...Its a good post..keep posting and update the information. Togel Singapore