Line of Buffer zone, Pittsburgh, PA
Spaces of Conflict
By Lori A. Brown
A related series of questions one may ask include what is the value of design thinking for the greater public in terms of abortion and public space? What role could architects have in exploring overlooked spaces like abortion clinics and engaging in their design and security? How can design positively impact access? Although not explicitly aligned with the types of non-places theorized by the anthropologist Marc Augé, reproductive healthcare facilities have a certain affinity coinciding with what as he states “[n]on-places could be seen, approaching them from another vantage point, as the heirs to everything that has created discomfort or annoyance in the history of human spaces.”[iii] Although the spaces of abortion are not the creator of discomfort, the idea of these spaces and what they represent definitely fall within this categorization and the physicality of their existences clearly create discomfort for a large segment of the population.
One of the initial issues that drew me to this research was the intersection of a highly politicized and charged space being contested out in the public realm. Public space is critical in different ways for abortion clinics. Anti-choice protestors regularly exercise their first amendment freedoms by protesting out in front of abortion clinics across the United States. This right is part of the freedom individual citizens of this country have to publicly speak out against issues one is against and anti-choice protestors are protected under law to be able to do so. State and federal courts have ruled both in support and in opposition to certain abortion rights cases weighing free speech against abortion access. This has produced a variety of legislation differing dramatically from state-to-state controlling and manipulating the actual geography and physical boundaries around clinic properties, buildings and people’s bodies.[iv] This remains ongoing and just this past January 2014 the Supreme Court heard arguments challenging the constitutionality of the 35’ buffer zones around abortion clinics in the state of Massachusetts.[v]
[i] This essay is part of a larger research project recently published in Contested Bodies: Abortion Clinics, Women’s Shelters and Hospitals (Ashgate 2013).
[ii] “The United States Constitution.” (n.d.).
[iii] On the Move 2012.
[iv] Madsen v. Women’s Health Center (1994) upheld noise restrictions during certain times of certain days. The FACE law (1994) protects anyone exercising their right to reproductive services and First Amendment religious freedoms and makes unlawful to intentionally damage or destroy facility property or places of worship. Schenck v. Pro-Choice Network of Western New York (1997) upheld a 15-foot fixed zone around doorways and doorway entrances, parking lots entrances, driveways and driveway entrance of the clinic facilities. Hill v. Colorado (2000) upheld 100-feet fixed zone around health care facilities and 8 feet bubble zone around someone entering and exiting a clinic.
[v] See Valencia 2014, Barnes 2014, Mauro 2014 and Totenberg 2014 for coverage on this case.
Outline:
1. Intro
2. Role of public space in research
a. discussion of some political theory literature including Jurgen Habermas, Nancy Fraser and Iris Marion Young
b. the public / private dichotomy and why this is problematic
c. how abortion clinics intersect within public space; where can agency be legible
d. role of the body, especially reproductive body, within public realm
3. spaces of possibility
a. role of design within build environment
b. Elizabeth Grosz asking how to think architecture differently – how do spaces of abortion provoke different possibilities?
4. case study: Kentucky (with mapping)
a. geography of access
b. state restrictions and spatial implications
c. alternatives to access: hospitals and pharmacies
d. cultural influences
5. conclusion
447 Comments – Login to comment
seobacklinksmaster · Jun 16, 26 12:56 pm
Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article.A11VO for excavatorseobacklinksmaster · Jun 16, 26 12:58 pm
Great! It sounds good. Thanks for sharing..A11VO for excavatorseobacklinksmaster · Jun 16, 26 12:59 pm
I read a lot of stuff and i found that the way of writing to clearifing that exactly want to say was very good so i am impressed and ilike to come again in future..A11VO for excavatorseobacklinksmaster · Jun 20, 26 9:38 am
Love to read it,Waiting For More new Update and I Already Read your Recent Post its Great Thanks.alexistogelseobacklinksmaster · Jun 22, 26 7:12 am
thank you for a great post.alexistogelanuskhan · Jun 22, 26 10:43 am
anuskhan · Jun 22, 26 10:46 am
It is a great website.. The Design looks very good.. Keep working like that!.high volume low competition digital marketing keywords 2026https://anuskhaninsights.com/high-volume-low-competition-keyword-guide-2026-anus-khan-insights/
seobacklinksmaster · Jun 24, 26 11:18 am
Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going.... I really enjoyed exploring your site. good resource...satta king 786 4 Jodiseobacklinksmaster · Jul 6, 26 7:58 am
Wonderful blog post offering practical knowledge for readers wanting reliable information online.alexistogel daftarseobacklinksmaster · Jul 7, 26 10:26 am
Amazing work creating informative content, appreciate your effort and valuable contribution always.toto macauseobacklinksmaster · Jul 8, 26 12:21 pm
Great blog sharing valuable information, looking forward to more educational posts from you.togel onlineseobacklinksmaster · Jul 9, 26 9:34 am
Wonderful blog post offering practical knowledge for readers wanting reliable information online.agen judi bolaseobacklinksmaster · Jul 11, 26 10:24 am
Great blog sharing valuable information, looking forward to more educational posts from you.situs judi bolabushrakhan · Jul 12, 26 10:22 am
Excellent post with practical tips, helping readers gain useful knowledge and understanding today. bandar toto macaubushrakhan · Jul 13, 26 1:26 am
Excellent post with practical tips, helping readers gain useful knowledge and understanding today. agen slot88seobacklinksmaster · Jul 13, 26 7:57 am
Helpful content presented professionally, appreciate your valuable effort and creative writing skills. alexistogel loginoscarmartin · Jul 13, 26 2:33 pm
Clothing manufacturers for startups provide low MOQ production, private label services, custom designs, and expert support to help new brands launch successfully. From sampling to bulk manufacturing, they deliver high-quality apparel, reliable production, and scalable solutions for growing businesses.
bushrakhan · Jul 14, 26 4:30 am
This article is well organized and very easy to understand for everyone.slot online
bushrakhan · Jul 19, 26 6:05 am
Great article with meaningful insights, thanks for helping readers understand complex topics.[url=https://www.mapisimo.cz/]bandar slot gacor[/url]bushrakhan · Jul 19, 26 6:05 am
Great article with meaningful insights, thanks for helping readers understand complex topics.bandar">https://www.mapisimo.cz/">bandar slot gacorbushrakhan · Jul 19, 26 8:16 am
Great article with meaningful insights, thanks for helping readers understand complex topics. bandar slot gacorseobacklinksmaster · Jul 20, 26 7:18 am
Amazing content with useful guidance, appreciate your commitment to quality writing and research.https://armenia.streetlifting.world/seobacklinksmaster · Jul 22, 26 4:13 am
Wonderful content providing educational value, appreciate your effort in creating informative articles. agen togelseobacklinksmaster · Jul 23, 26 8:47 am
Great blog post with meaningful insights, thanks for sharing your valuable expertise today. alexistogel daftarseobacklinksmaster · Jul 25, 26 6:21 am
Really enjoyed this informative content, appreciate your effort in writing such articles.alexistogel">https://alexisnaero.com/">alexistogel daftarseobacklinksmaster · Jul 26, 26 6:01 am
This article is well organized and very easy to understand for everyone.bandar togelseobacklinksmaster · Jul 26, 26 8:05 am
Very informative content with practical advice, thank you for sharing your experience.situs">https://clutchmodern.com/bar-cabinets-carts/">situs toto onlineseobacklinksmaster · Jul 27, 26 3:00 am
Your article is informative, engaging, and extremely helpful for every interested reader. situs toto onlineseobacklinksmaster · Jul 27, 26 10:15 am
Amazing work with valuable information, keep publishing more quality articles regularly. agen slot88seobacklinksmaster · Jul 28, 26 7:28 am
Very informative content with practical advice, thank you for sharing your experience. https://cydiageeks.com/add-people-snapchat-using-phone-number/seobacklinksmaster · Jul 28, 26 7:29 am
Excellent article that is easy to understand and highly beneficial for everyone. toto macauseobacklinksmaster · Jul 28, 26 12:19 pm
Excellent article that is easy to understand and highly beneficial for everyone.alexistogel daftarseobacklinksmaster · Jul 29, 26 9:21 am
Great writing style making this article enjoyable, educational, and easy to understand. bandar slot gacorseobacklinksmaster · Aug 3, 26 11:24 am
Thank you for publishing this excellent article filled with meaningful and useful information.slot online gacorbushrakhan · Aug 4, 26 6:58 am
Excellent blog sharing informative ideas and useful suggestions for interested readers everywhere. rtp slot onlineseobacklinksmaster · Aug 5, 26 4:01 am
Amazing article with practical insights, thanks for helping readers improve their knowledge. bandar slot onlineseobacklinksmaster · Aug 5, 26 9:22 am
Wonderful explanation supported by useful examples, really enjoyed reading this informative article. togelnaveedmughal · Aug 6, 26 9:42 am
Excellent article with meaningful content, thanks for your effort and professional knowledge sharing.alexistogel daftarnaveedmughal · Aug 7, 26 9:46 am
Wonderful article containing practical advice, thank you for sharing your expertise with everyone.toto macaunaveedmughal · Aug 15, 26 10:35 am
Amazing guide offering useful advice, appreciate your dedication to creating valuable online content.situs slot onlinenaveedmughal · Aug 25, 26 12:27 pm
Helpful information presented professionally, looking forward to reading your upcoming blog posts.togel onlinenaveedmughal · Aug 27, 26 10:13 am
Great effort behind this informative post, really appreciate your dedication and knowledge.situs slot gacornaveedmughal · Aug 30, 26 10:03 am
Wonderful explanation with useful tips, thanks for making this topic easy today.alexistogel loginnaveedmughal · Aug 31, 26 7:58 am
Great article helping readers understand important concepts through simple and effective explanations.alexistogel loginbushrakhan · Sep 1, 26 4:49 am
Wonderful explanation supported by useful examples, really enjoyed reading this informative article. alexistogel alternatifnaveedmughal · Sep 1, 26 7:15 am
Great article with meaningful insights, thanks for helping readers understand complex topics.togel onlinenaveedmughal · Sep 1, 26 2:09 pm
Amazing article with simple explanations, making difficult concepts easier for everyone today.togel online