The Space of the Commons: Dheisheh Refugee Camp

By Alison Hugill and Dan Dorocic

Hannah Arendt’s essay ‘Labour, Work, Action,’ published in 1958, produces a definition of action and public space that is decidedly connected to a politically liberal-democratic tradition. Lacking any materialist nuance and explicitly anti-Marxist, Arendt’s treatise proposes that the actions of individuals – their capacity to begin ever anew within a plurality of beings - is what distinguishes them and reveals the meaning of each human life. Every man’s words and deeds form a part of their personal (and thus implicitly social) narrative. Arendt’s depreciation of labour, both productive and reproductive, allows her to perform a theoretical reversal of Marx: instead, she privileges action as the main pillar of the human condition, arguing that labour relates to mere biological life and necessity.

From a Marxist perspective, it is clear that capitalist social relations are deeply entwined with each layer of Arendt’s “human condition” and, while they may manifest most transparently in the realm of labour, they are inextricable from individual pursuits in terms of action and they permeate modern notions of both public and private space. In reality, the so-called “public realm” (the space of action in Arendt’s reading) is not free or independent from state or economic imperatives. On the contrary, the public realm, as we now know it, is saturated with these concerns.

This paper will examine the fraught question of public space in the Palestinian context, with particular reference to on-going projects in the Dheisheh refugee camp near Bethlehem in the West Bank. Public space and participatory spatial initiatives will be investigated to understand their relevance and potential in this context. The Arendtian idea of “unique and free individuals” working on a collective project is problematic here. Instead, many refugees living in Dheisheh are seeking to actively build common political spaces that exist independent of institutional or governmental bodies, individual economic pursuits or the apparatus of occupation. In particular, a group within Campus in Camps (an educational and project-oriented program developed out of the Camp Improvement Program) is interrogating the ‘Unbuilt’ spaces in Dheisheh.[1] Participants have isolated several sites within Dheisheh that have the potential to be transformed for collective use.

Following the work of the Decolonizing Architecture Art Residency (DAAR) and Campus in Camps, we will position the case of the public realm and action within the theoretical and political framework of the “commons”[2] and "dissensus"[3], against traditional, liberal and neoliberal understandings of the political ‘space of appearance.’

-------------------------------------------------------------

[1] Ahmad Laham, Aysar Alaify, Isshaq Albarbary, Qussay Abu Aker (Campus in Camps participants), The Unbuilt, June 2013. http://www.campusincamps.ps/projects/09-the-unbuilt/

[2] Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, Commonwealth. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass. 2009.

Silvia Federici, “Feminism and the Politics of the Commons,” posted in The Commoner: A Web Journal for Other Values. www.commoner.org

[3] Jacques Ranciere, “The Thinking of Dissensus: Politics and Aesthetics,” in Reading Ranciere. Eds. Paul Bowman and Richard Stamp. Continuum. London and New York, 2011.

  • manthan.anra

    manthan.anra ·  Dec 26, 25 7:01 am

    A helpful resource for business owners who want to stay competitive using AI tools.
    https://toolora.biz/category/ai-tools/ai-tools-for-small-business/
  • sakshimittal11111111

    sakshimittal11111111 ·  Jan 2, 26 3:35 am

    We are Happy to Provides you our lust service at your location, Book our Sensual Call Girls in jaipur, they are fully loaded with Passion of love to make with you.

  • sakshimittal11111111

    sakshimittal11111111 ·  Jan 2, 26 3:45 am

    Mashymi offering a unique and exciting experience for those people who are looking for an intimate and sensual experience. Whether you are looking for a discreet and passionate encounter or a playful and naughty adventure, the services of mashymi.in can provide the perfect solution.

  • sakshimittal11111111

    sakshimittal11111111 ·  Jan 2, 26 3:46 am

    Discover the allure of Chandigarh call girls sophisticated, stunning companions ready to elevate your evenings with charm, discretion, and unforgettable experiences.

  • rupalikaur1

    rupalikaur1 ·  Jan 3, 26 10:02 am

    Hello, my name is Rupali Kaur Call - 9004422804 and I am an elite girl at Mumbai Escorts. 
    https://www.rupali-kaur.com/     
    https://www.triptipatel.com/
    https://www.poojamehta.net/
    https://www.arpitagoyal.com/
    https://www.natashakhan.biz/
    https://www.rupali-kaur.com/mumbai-airport-escorts.html
    https://www.arpitagoyal.com/call-girls-in-mumbai-airport.html
    https://www.triptipatel.com/mumbai-airport-escorts.html
    https://www.poojamehta.net/mumbai-airport-escorts.html
    https://www.rupali-kaur.com/vashi-escorts.html 
    https://www.rupali-kaur.com/andheri-escorts.html
    https://www.rupali-kaur.com/thane-escorts.html 
  • rupalikaur1

    rupalikaur1 ·  Jan 3, 26 10:03 am

    https://jagritimalhotra.webnode.page/
    https://jagritimalhotra.weebly.com/
    https://ranikali.weebly.com/
    https://ranikali4.webnode.page/
    https://rupali-kaur.weebly.com/
    https://rupalikaur.freeescortsite.com/
    https://rupalikaur4.freeescortsite.com/ 
    https://arpitagoyal4.freeescortsite.com/
    https://poojamehta.freeescortsite.com/
    https://triptipatel.freeescortsite.com/
  • rupalikaur1

    rupalikaur1 ·  Jan 3, 26 10:03 am

    https://mumbai-escorts4u.freeescortsite.com/
    https://poojamehta.escortbook.com/
    https://poojamehta1.escortbook.com/
    https://triptipatel.escortbook.com/
    https://rupalikaur.escortbook.com/
    https://rupali-kaur.topescortsite.com/
    https://arpitagoyal4.mystrikingly.com/
    https://arpitagoyal.website3.me/


  • mahiverma

    mahiverma ·  Jan 7, 26 5:30 am

    Call me 24×7 I am Divyakaur 23 years old sexy call girl services near me. If you wanna quality time spend it with me depending on your choice short time and overnight at a very low payment Get in touch with me and meet for coffee, dinner, or just for sharing personal activity. Try to connect with me first to know what my expertise is and get the most amazing memorable experience of your life. 
    Akurdi Call Girls
    Aundh Call Girls
    Baner Call Girls
    Chinchwad Call Girls
    Dehu Road Call Girls
    Hadapsar Call Girls
    Hinjewadi Call Girls
    Kalyani Nagar Call Girls
    Khandala Call Girls
    Koregaon Park Call Girls
    Kothrud Call Girls
    Lonavala Call Girls
    Magarpatta Call Girls
    Nigdi Call Girls
  • hydfun

    hydfun ·  Jan 8, 26 6:33 am

    Are you in Gachibowli, a very posh and important area of Hyderabad? This affluent neighborhood of Hyderabad is famous for its embassies and consulates from various countries. So it is no surprise to find Gachibowli call girls so beautiful and sexy. These sophisticated call girls are called upon to serve the physical and emotional needs of diplomats and high-flying officers. If you are in the area for a while, you too can enjoy the wonderful experience of Gachibowli call girls.

    Huge Variety of Gachibowli call girls

    Yes, it is true that the big and soft curves of a mature housewife attract most of the men. However, there is no dearth of clients who find tall and slim young college girls more attractive. As this neighborhood receives large number of foreign nationals, we have beautiful Russian girls to meet the needs of these guys. Finally, we have amazing model girls to take care of men in need who are captivated by the beauty and charisma of movie actresses. No matter what your preference is, you will find that we have more Gachibowli call girls to keep you happy and satisfied.

    Why choose a sexy Bhabhi as Gachibowli call girl?

    If you are a new customer or if you are very tired, then the best partner for you in Gachibowli is going to be a mature housewife with big and soft curves. It is obvious that you are not interested in working hard and this is where these Gachibowli call girl prove to be so valuable. With their massive boobs and ass, your sexy bhabhi easily casts a magical spell on your senses. Play with her melons as she rides you to introduce you to a whole new world of physical pleasures. These recently married housewives are highly experienced in the art of intercourse and know what it takes to make their client happy and satisfied.

    Cute College Girls For Some Thrill And Action

    If you are unhappy with sex life then returning home then there is no need to worry. It happens after a few years when sex becomes monotonous and you find your spouse unattractive to loose skin and saggy breasts. We have dozens of amazing young call girls in Gachibowli ready to prove their hospitality skills in front of you. These smart and sexy college girls work as part time call girls to meet the expenses of a lavish lifestyle. Your young partner will give an awesome performance in bed and easily pose as your girlfriend in the outdoors. You will find these Gachibowli call girls in large numbers on our website and you also know about or read about lifestyle blogs, You will know everything after get the information.

    Fulfill your wishes with Gachibowli call girls

    When you go through pictures of Russian girls and model girls on our website, be sure to read the post description with their pictures. You will learn about their special services such as position 69, blow job without condom and anal sex. Talk to the chosen call girl on WhatsApp number to fulfill your sexual desires. Shamshabad Call Girl | Kukatpally Call Girl | Mallapur Call Girl | Hitech City Call Girl | Habsiguda Call Girl | Jubilee Hills Call Girl | Secunderabad Call Girl | Banjara Hills Call Girl

  • jagmohankumawat

    jagmohankumawat ·  Jan 8, 26 12:16 pm

    Your post is very interesting to me. Reading was so much fun. I think the reason reading is fun is because it is a post related to that I am interested in. Articles related to you are the best. I would like you to write a similar post about !

    Choose a trusted Udaipur escort service featuring classy, professional companions. Our platform ensures privacy, easy booking, and premium standards for clients seeking reliable and elegant escort solutions.

    Check Out More Details At :-     https://udaipur.tottaa.com/

    • BRACKET [takes action]

    Housing Resistant Forms of Life

    Housing Resistant Forms of Life

    By Hamed Khosravi
    Shared Grammars, Individual Desires: Participatory Planning and Slum Upgrading in Brazil

    Shared Grammars, Individual Desires: Participatory Planning and Slum Upgrading in Brazil

    By Gabriel Duarte
    Open House

    Open House

    By Matthew Mazzotta
    Mobile Loitering: public infrastructure for a highly gendered urban context

    Mobile Loitering: public infrastructure for a highly gendered urban context

    By Mariam Kamara, Elizabeth Golden
    See that my grave is kept clean: ritual continuity & spatial resistance along Futenma's inverted periphery

    See that my grave is kept clean: ritual continuity & spatial resistance along Futenma's inverted periphery

    By Steven Chodoriwsky
    A Subject of Action

    A Subject of Action

    By Albert Pope
    Place de la Republique in Paris

    Place de la Republique in Paris

    By TVK - Trévelo & Viger-Kohler Architectes Urbanistes
    THE IMAGE OF THE SQUARE: Redefining Citizenship by Design

    THE IMAGE OF THE SQUARE: Redefining Citizenship by Design

    By Samaa Elimam
    Delirious actions: gender tactics in public space

    Delirious actions: gender tactics in public space

    By Serafina Amoroso

    ELASTIC COMMEMORATION

    ELASTIC COMMEMORATION

    By Guy Königstein
    BREAKING INTO THE CITY Urban explorers' architectural posture

    BREAKING INTO THE CITY Urban explorers' architectural posture

    By Michael Cook
    Off the Wall

    Off the Wall

    By Katherine Jenkins, Parker Sutton
    Cultivate Collective

    Cultivate Collective

    By De Peter Yi
    FAS: Architectural Activism

    FAS: Architectural Activism

    By FAS- Foreign Architects Switzerland
    What a body can do: the political as generator of a common spatiality

    What a body can do: the political as generator of a common spatiality

    By Lucia Jalon Oyarzun
    Bronx is Up, WTC is down: paraphrasing Leonard Bernstein. A public service guerilla action for Architecture League’s Make a Difference in Two Days

    Bronx is Up, WTC is down: paraphrasing Leonard Bernstein. A public service guerilla action for Architecture League’s Make a Difference in Two Days

    By Austin+Mergold With James Bowman, Denise Ramzy, Sally Reynolds
    Contested Energies

    Contested Energies

    By Stephen Mueller, Ersela Kripa
    Spaces of Conflict

    Spaces of Conflict

    By Lori A. Brown
    The Empty City

    The Empty City

    By Martin Sztyk
    SLANTED MEMORIAL

    SLANTED MEMORIAL

    By Jin Young Song
    Next page » Loading