The Space of the Commons: Dheisheh Refugee Camp
By Alison Hugill and Dan Dorocic
Hannah Arendt’s essay ‘Labour, Work, Action,’ published in 1958, produces a definition of action and public space that is decidedly connected to a politically liberal-democratic tradition. Lacking any materialist nuance and explicitly anti-Marxist, Arendt’s treatise proposes that the actions of individuals – their capacity to begin ever anew within a plurality of beings - is what distinguishes them and reveals the meaning of each human life. Every man’s words and deeds form a part of their personal (and thus implicitly social) narrative. Arendt’s depreciation of labour, both productive and reproductive, allows her to perform a theoretical reversal of Marx: instead, she privileges action as the main pillar of the human condition, arguing that labour relates to mere biological life and necessity.
From a Marxist perspective, it is clear that capitalist social relations are deeply entwined with each layer of Arendt’s “human condition” and, while they may manifest most transparently in the realm of labour, they are inextricable from individual pursuits in terms of action and they permeate modern notions of both public and private space. In reality, the so-called “public realm” (the space of action in Arendt’s reading) is not free or independent from state or economic imperatives. On the contrary, the public realm, as we now know it, is saturated with these concerns.
This paper will examine the fraught question of public space in the Palestinian context, with particular reference to on-going projects in the Dheisheh refugee camp near Bethlehem in the West Bank. Public space and participatory spatial initiatives will be investigated to understand their relevance and potential in this context. The Arendtian idea of “unique and free individuals” working on a collective project is problematic here. Instead, many refugees living in Dheisheh are seeking to actively build common political spaces that exist independent of institutional or governmental bodies, individual economic pursuits or the apparatus of occupation. In particular, a group within Campus in Camps (an educational and project-oriented program developed out of the Camp Improvement Program) is interrogating the ‘Unbuilt’ spaces in Dheisheh.[1] Participants have isolated several sites within Dheisheh that have the potential to be transformed for collective use.
Following the work of the Decolonizing Architecture Art Residency (DAAR) and Campus in Camps, we will position the case of the public realm and action within the theoretical and political framework of the “commons”[2] and "dissensus"[3], against traditional, liberal and neoliberal understandings of the political ‘space of appearance.’-------------------------------------------------------------
[1] Ahmad Laham, Aysar Alaify, Isshaq Albarbary, Qussay Abu Aker (Campus in Camps participants), The Unbuilt, June 2013. http://www.campusincamps.ps/projects/09-the-unbuilt/
[2] Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, Commonwealth. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass. 2009.
Silvia Federici, “Feminism and the Politics of the Commons,” posted in The Commoner: A Web Journal for Other Values. www.commoner.org
[3] Jacques Ranciere, “The Thinking of Dissensus: Politics and Aesthetics,” in Reading Ranciere. Eds. Paul Bowman and Richard Stamp. Continuum. London and New York, 2011.

1302 Comments – Login to comment
delhicg11 · May 6, 25 4:47 am
Delhi Escorts Delhi Russian Escorts Connaught Place Call Girls Defence Colony Call Girls Malviya Nagar Call Girls Saket Escorts Chanakyapuri Call Girls Dwarka Mor Call Girls Hauz Khas Escorts Mahipalpur Call Girls Shahdara Escorts Rohini Escorts Karol Bagh Escorts Mayur Vihar Call Girls Paharganj Call Girls Aerocity Escorts Kalkaji Escorts Nehru Place Escorts Punjabi Bagh Escorts Vasant Kunj Call Girls Lajpat Nagar Call Girls Lakshmi Nagar Escorts Uttam Nagar Escorts Mehrauli Escorts Rk Puram Call Girls Cr Park Escorts Dhaula Kuan Call Girls Chhatarpur Escorts Noida Escorts Service Gurgaon Escorts Service Ghaziabad Escorts Service Faridabad Escorts Service Real Escorts Girls Photos Delhi Call Girls Contact Number Call Girls Service In The Royal Plaza Hotel The Royal Plaza Call Girls Service In Leemeredian Hotel Leemeridan Hotel Call Girls Service In Sangrila Hotel Shangri La Hotel Call Girls Service In The Lalit Hotel The Lalit Hotel Call Girls Service In The Claridges Hotel The Claridges Hotel Call Girls Service In The Leela Palace Hotel The Leela Palace Hotel Call Girls Service In The Palace Hotel Taj Palace Hotel Call Girls Service In Taj Man Singh Hotel Taj Man Singh Hotel Call Girls Service In The Lodhi Hotel The Lodhi Hotel Call Girls Service In Obrai Hotel Oberoi Hotel Call Girls Service In Itc Morya Hotel Itc Morya Hotel Call Girls Service In The Ashok Hotel The Ashok Hotel Call Girls Service In Sheraton Hotel Sheraton Hotel Call Girls Service In Ajanta Hotel Ajanta Hotel Call Girls Service In The Grand Hotel The Grand Hotel Russian Call Girls In Call Girls In Delhi Escorts Greater Noida Escorts Service Dwarka Call Girls Greater Kailash Call Girls South Escorts Service Kashmiri Gate Call Girls East Escorts Service New Friends Colony Escorts West Escorts Service Vasant Vihar Escorts Vivek Vihar Call Girls Delhi Independent Escorts Delhi Ncr Escorts Blogs Escorts Janakpuri Call Girls Civil Lines Escorts Daryaganj Escorts Delhi Gate Call Girls Golf Links Escorts Kingsway Camp Model Town Call Girls Patel Nagar Call Girls Patparganj Call Girls Pitampura Call Girls Preet Vihar Call Girls Rajouri Garden Escorts Seelampur Call Girls Alwar Escorts Service Baghpat Escorts Service Bharatpur Escorts Service Bhiwani Escorts Service Bulandshahr Escorts Service Hapur Escorts Service Jhajjhar Escorts Service Jind Escorts Service Karnal Escorts Service Mahendragarh Escorts Service Charkhi Dadri Escorts Service Gautam Budh Nagar Escorts Service Meerut Escorts Service Palwal Escorts Service Panipat Escorts Service Rewari Escorts Service Shamli Escorts Service Adarsh Nagar Escorts Aiims Call Girls Ajmeri Gate Escorts Alipur Call Girls Anand Parbat Escorts Anand Vihar Call Girls Arjun Nagar Escorts Ashram Call Girls Azad Nagar Escorts Azadpur Call Girls Babarpur Escorts Badli Call Girls Bapa Nagar Escorts Barakhamba Road Call Girls Bawana Escorts Begumpur Call Girls Ber Sarai Escorts Bhagwan Das Road Call Girls Bharat Nagar Escorts Bhogal Call Girls Bijwasan Escorts Brahmpuri Call Girls Budh Vihar Escorts Burari Call Girls Chaman Vihar Escorts Chandni Chowk Escorts Chawri Bazar Call Girls Chirag Call Girls Dabri Call Girls Devli Escorts Dilshad Garden Escorts Panchsheel Park Escorts Jharoda Majra Burari Escorts Akshar Dham Call Girls Aya Nagar Escorts Chhawla Call Girls Rajender Nagar Escorts Chokhandi Call Girls Delhi Cantoment Escorts Wazirpur Escorts Subhash Nagar Call Girls Bhajanpura Escorts Kalindi Kunj Call Girls Badarpur Escorts Siraspur Call Girls Ganesh Nagar Escorts Harsh Vihar Call Girls Balbir Nagar Escorts Rani Bagh Call Girls East Of Kailash Escorts Fatehpur Beri Call Girls Gagan Vihar Escorts Gautam Nagar Call Girls Geeta Colony Escorts Ghazipur Call Girls Ghitorni Escorts Gokalpur Call Girls Gole Market Call Girls Govindpuri Escorts Green Park Escorts Gtb Nagar Escorts Gujranwala Town Call Girls Gulabi Bagh Escorts Hari Nagar Call Girls Nizamuddin Call Girls Inder Enclave Escorts Inderlok Call Girls Inderpuri Escorts Indraprastha Call Girls Jahangir Puri Escorts Jangpura Escorts Jasola Call Girls Jhandewalan Escorts Johripur Call Girls Jor Bagh Escorts Kailash Colony Call Girls Kamla Nagar Call Girls Kapashera Escorts Karkardooma Call Girls Karampura Escorts Karawal Nagar Call Girls Katwaria Sarai Escorts Keshavpuram Call Girls Khajoori Khas Escorts Khan Market Call Girls Khanpur Escorts Khureji Call Girls Lado Sarai Escorts Lal Kuan Call Girls Lodi Colony Escorts Madangir Call Girls Madanpur Khadar Escorts Maharani Bagh Call Girls Mahavir Enclave Escorts Maidangarhi Escorts Mandawali Escorts Mandi House Call Girls Sadiq Nagar Escorts Safdarjung Call Girls Sarai Kale Khan Call Girls Sarai Rohilla Escorts Sarita Vihar Call Girls Sarojini Nagar Escorts Satbari Call Girls Savita Vihar Escorts Savitri Nagar Call Girls Sheikh Sarai Escorts Shadipur Call Girls Shakarpur Call Girls Shakti Nagar Escorts Shalimar Bagh Call Girls Shastri Park Escorts Seemapuri Call Girls Soami Nagar Escorts Sonia Vihar Call Girls Nirman Vihar Call Girls Okhla Escorts Palam Airport Escorts Pandav Nagar Call Girls Paschim Vihar Escorts Pira Garhi Escorts Pragati Maidan Escorts Pushp Vihar Call Girls Ramesh Nagar Call Girls Rithala Escorts Sadar Bazar Call Girls Vishal Enclave Escorts Wazirabad Escorts West Enclave Call Girls Yamuna Vihar Escorts Yojana Vihar Call Girls Yusuf Sarai Escorts Vaishali Call Girls Loknayakpuram Escorts Shastri Nagar Call Girls Kirti Nagar Escorts Kanjhawala Call Girls Kakrola Escorts Dera Mandi Call Girls Ashok Vihar Escorts Dashrath Puri Escorts Bindapur Call Girls Manglapuri Escorts Mangolpuri Call Girls Mayapuri Escorts Moti Bagh Escorts Moti Nagar Call Girls Mukherjee Nagar Escorts Mundka Call Girls Munirka Escorts Najafgarh Call Girls Nangloi Escorts Naraina Call Girls Narela Escorts Navjeevan Vihar Call Girls Nawada Escorts Neb Sarai Call Girls New Ashok Nagar Call Girls Sunlight Colony Escorts Vijay Nagar Call Girls Greater Kailash Escorts Alaknanda Call Girls Kalu Sarai Escorts Panchsheel Enclave Call Girls Goyla Village Escorts Mansarover Garden Call Girls Dakshinpuri Escorts Sagar Pur Call Girls Shakurpur Escorts Kondli Call Girls Jaitpur Escorts Deenpur Call Girls Daya Basti Escorts Gopalpur Village Call Girls Rangpuri Escorts Khera Kalan Call Girls Nangal Raya Escorts Singhu Call Girls Ranaji Enclave Escorts Central Secretariat Call Girls Swasthya Vihar Escorts Ip Estate Call Girls Ansari Nagar Escorts Chittaranjan Call Girls India Gate Escorts Lodi Road Call Girls New Mustafabad Escorts Qutabgarh Call Girls Shakur Basti Escorts Tagore Garden Call Girls South Ex Escorts Sukhdev Vihar Call Girls Sultanpuri Escorts Sundar Nagar Call Girls Tagore Garden Escorts Tilak Marg Call Girls Tilak Nagar Escorts Timarpur Call Girls Tis Hazari Escorts Trilokpuri Call Girls Tri Nagar Escorts Tughlakabad Call Girls Vasundhara Enclave Call Girls Vigyan Vihar Escorts Vikas Kunj Call Girls Vikas Puri Escorts Vinod Nagar Call Girls Tilangpur Kotla Escorts Bhalswa Call Girls Vishnu Garden Escorts Qutub Vihar Call Girls Prem Nagar Escorts Nilothi Call Girls Kalyan Vihar Escorts Sultanpur Call Girls Bakhtawarpur Escorts Chittaranjan Park Call Girls Sidhartha Nagar Escorts Kidwai Nagar Call Girls Adchini Escorts Karala Call Girls Ashok Nagar Escorts Bahapur Call Girls Bakkar Wala Escorts Hastsal Call Girls Mustafabad Escorts Sri Niwaspuri Call Girls Mukundpur Escorts Krishna Nagar Call Girls Sangam Vihar Escorts Malka Ganj Call Girls Lawrence Road Escorts Jamia Nagar Call Girls Sainik Farm Escorts Vijay Vihar Call Girls Gandhi Nagar Escorts Fateh Nagar Call Girls Khirki Extension Escorts Pulpahladpur Call Girls Roop Nagar Escorts Sant Nagar Call Girls Bali Nagar Escorts Raja Garden Call Girls Jhilmil Colony Escorts Matiala Call Girls Raj Nagar Escorts Razapur Khurd Call Girls Mithapur Escorts Ranhola Call Girls Kair Escorts Sawda Call Girls Dwarka L Zone Escorts Ranjeet Nagar Call Girls Village Mandoli Call Girls Mohan Garden Escorts Neeti Bagh Call Girls Shanti Niketan Escorts Hauz Khas Call Girls Uday Park Escortspiyasen1111111 · May 6, 25 8:59 am
Avni dutta Kolkata Escorts offers an exceptional outcall service to hotels
. The city, renowned for its captivating charm and often referred to as the hub Kolkata escort of desires, provides numerous opportunities to fulfill your wishes. It consistently entertains and offers premier Kolkata escort service to help you experience the night of your dreams. By choosing our Call Girls Escort in Kolkata, ?kolkata female escort The best escorts in Kolkata deliver you with Kolkata Russian Escorts Kolkata Russian Escort Russian Escort in Kolkata Russian Escorts in Kolkata Russian Call Girls in Kolkata Russian Call Girl in Kolkata Russian Call Girls Russian Call Girl Kolkata Russian Call Girls Kolkata Russian Call Girl Russian Escorts Russian Escort Kolkata Russian Escort Service Kolkata Russian Escorts Service Kolkata Russian Escort Services Russian Escort Service Russian Escorts Service Russian Escort Services Russian Escorts Services Russian Escort Service in kolkata Kolkata Russian Female Escorts Kolkata Russian Female Escort
we guarantee to make your evening both special and unforgettable. Reasons to select our escort service Kolkata We understand that you seek a higher standard of service. When you choose one of the most luxurious escorts in Kolkata, we ensure that the reservation process is tailored to your preferences, allowing you to select the Kolkata Female escort that aligns with your comfort and style. Our clients are always our top priority. Female Escorts Kolkata Russian Female Escort Siliguri Escorts|| Siliguri Escort|| Siliguri Escort Service|| Siliguri Female Escorts|| Siliguri Female Escort|| Siliguri Independent Escorts|| Siliguri Independent Escort|| Siliguri Escorts Service?|| Siliguri Escorts Services|| Escorts SiliguriShapoorji Escorts|| Shapoorji Escort|| Shapoorji Escort Service|| Shapoorji Female Escorts|| Shapoorji Female Escort|| Shapoorji Independent Escorts Salt Lake Escorts|| Salt Lake Escort|| Salt Lake Escort Service|| Salt Lake Female Escorts|| Salt Lake Female Escort|| Salt Lake Independent Escorts|| Salt Lake Independent Escort Newtown Escorts|| Newtown Escort|| Newtown Escort Service|| Newtown Female Escorts|| Newtown Female Escort|| Newtown Independent Escorts|| Newtown Independent Escort|| Newtown Escorts Service?|| Newtown Escorts ServicesPark Street Escorts|| Park Street Escort|| Park Street Escort Service|| Park Street Female Escorts|| Park Street Female Escort|| Park Street Independent Escorts|| Park Street Independent Escort|| Park Street Escorts Service?|| Park Street Escorts ServicesSalt Lake Escorts|| Salt Lake Escort|| Salt Lake Escort Service|| Salt Lake Female Escorts|| Salt Lake Female Escort|| Salt Lake Independent Escorts|| Salt Lake Independent Escort|| Salt Lake Escorts Service?|| Salt Lake Escorts Services|| Escorts Salt Lake
Russian call girls || Russian call girl || Kolkata Russian Escort Service || Kolkata Russian Escorts || Russian Escort || Russian Escorts || Russian Escort Service || Kolkata Russian Escort || Russian Escort In Kolkata || Russian Escorts In Kolkata || Russian Escort Service In Kolkata || Kolkata Russian call girl || Kolkata Russian call girls || Russian call girls Kolkata || Russian call girl Kolkata || Russian call girls In Kolkata || Russian call girl In Kolkata ||hotel Escorts|| hotel Escort|| hotel Escort Service|| hotel Female Escorts|| hotel Female Escort|| hotel Independent Escorts||Housewife Escorts|| Housewife Escort|| Housewife Escort Service|| Housewife Female Escorts|| Housewife Female Escort|| Housewife Independent Escorts|| Housewife Independnet Escort|| Housewife Escorts Service?|| Housewife Escorts Services|| Escorts Housewife||
Air hostess Escorts|| Air hostess Escort|| Air hostess Escort Service|| Air hostess Female Escorts|| Air hostess Female Escort|| Air hostess Independent Escorts|| Air hostess Independnet Escort|| Air hostess Escorts Service?|| Air hostess Escorts Services|| Escorts Air hostess|| Escort Air hostess|| Escorts in Air hostess|| Escort in Air hostess|| Air hostess College Girls Escorts|| Air hostess Call Girls|| Air hostess Call Girl|| Air hostess VIP Call Girls|| Air hostess VIP Call Girl|| Air hostess VIP Sexy Call Girls|| Escort Service Air hostess|| Escort Service in Air hostess|| Air hostess VIP Escorts|| Air hostess VIP Escort|| Air hostess Model Escorts|| Air hostess Model Escort|| Air hostess Model Call Girls|| Air hostess Model Call Girl Enhance your visit with a memorable experience Business professionals frequently visit Kolkata model escort and stay in hotels. There’s no need to scour the internet or make numerous calls; simply explore our Kolkata Hotel Escorts website. If you are a local resident seeking escort service in kolkata, you can rely on our esteemed agency. You can hire our services for a few hours, an entire evening, or even several days. Kolkata escorts services Visit our website and reach out to us anytime, 24/7. We pride ourselves on our robust customer care service. kolkata Independent escorts|| Independent escort|| Independent escorts|| Independent escort kolkata|| Independent escorts kolkata|| Independent escort in kolkata|| Independent escorts in kolkata|| kolkata female escorts|| kolkata female escort You can book our services from anywhere at any time. We will ensure that a stunning escort Kolkata arrives at your hotel room promptly. Our professional escorts are skilled in providing both mental and physical support, and we offer experienced ladies who can deliver complete physical satisfaction.