Off the Wall
By Katherine Jenkins and Parker Sutton
Deviant ACTION – subversive, reactive
“The distinction between the private and public realms, seen from the viewpoint of privacy rather than of the body politic, equals the distinction between things that should be shown and things that should be hidden.”
Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition (72)
There is a boundary dispute along the walls of San Francisco. A contest between two acts of preservation. The first is an act of self-preservation, or Arendtian self-actualization: the graffiti signature, or “tag,” is a declaration of the presence of the artist. The second act is one of masking, washing, obscuring the first - “buffing,” as it is known. This is building preservation. Neither act is frequently witnessed, but their resultant compositions - action and reaction - are a constant presence throughout much of the city. Reliefs of layered paint, mismatched color, strange collages of shapes that abstract the writing beneath: each marks an event in this ongoing exchange.
Though two dimensional, the accretion of marks on a facade has spatial and temporal implications; each layer of graffiti and its subsequent masking occurs at a distinct moment. The concealing marks - often intended to blend with the remaining facade - heighten the contrast between old and new and “create the condition for remembrance” (Human Condition, 8). Read across the whole of San Francisco, these acts of concealment reveal that the city itself is quite literally fading.
The cumulative effect of this process is the creation of a spatial register of civic tensions - demographic, cultural, public, private - that propel the city. Moreover, the insistent cycle of mark-making and obfuscation conjures a sustained space of appearance by Arendt’s own preconditions. Within this space of appearance, broader questions of ownership are raised: who owns the sidewalk? And who owns the neighborhood? The answers to these questions and the ensuing queries they arouse - how tall may one build? for whom must one provide? - are long the subject of debate in the Bay, where NIMBY-ism was not born but has indeed flourished.
Incidences of painted-over graffiti are most abundant where questions of ownership, gentrification, and collateral political action are greatest: the Mission District, South of Market (SOMA), and Potrero Hill. In these neighborhoods, palimpsests of masked graffiti are visible on nearly every block.
Couched within a broader narrative of theoretical discourse, such compositions evoke mid-century connections between the architectural volume and the painted plane first elicited by Robert Slutzky and Colin Rowe in their seminal writings on transparency. Like phenomenal transparency as they describe it, painted-over facades are charged with multiple perspectives and a compressed time scale, conjuring an activated field in the narrow space between the volume and plane. It differs in two critical regards: the phenomenally transparent facade compositions articulate the views of multiple actors, rather than just one, and their creation is decidedly more public - both of which make these compositions inherently political.
Architects have long agonized over the aesthetic and performative qualities of the facade, but its role as a repository for civic narrative and political speech is rarely identified or integrated into its design. How might this physically narrow plane do more to negotiate the political friction it presently wears?
277 Comments – Login to comment
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:10 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:11 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:12 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:13 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:14 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:25 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:26 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:27 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:29 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:30 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:31 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:32 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:33 am
vijendersinghalwariya · Jul 22, 23 11:34 am
mehwishyaqoob · Jul 25, 23 5:24 am
Wow, this blog post is incredibly insightful! I never thought about that from this perspective before. The author's writing style is engaging and kept me hooked from start to finish. I'll definitely be coming back for more. Great job
Best Digital Marketing in USA
curamaids · Aug 4, 23 3:13 am
Wow, this blog post is incredibly informative and well-written! The author has done a fantastic job. Thanks for Sharing.
Best House Cleaning Service in Raleigh
asimseo · Aug 20, 23 2:43 am
Dallas Cowboys blankets become cherished memorabilia, preserving the excitement of unforgettable games and seasons. dallas cowboys fleece blanketasimseo · Aug 20, 23 10:47 am
ChatGPT also has some notable translation weaknesses currently: ChatGPT translationshaikhseo · Aug 21, 23 3:09 am
Stay up to date with the latest economic developments, inflation rates, interest rate changes, and their impact on personal finances.What risks are involved in using ChatGPT for investment recommendations?asimseo · Aug 21, 23 12:38 pm
ChatGPT simulates human conversation, enabling seamless interactions that mirror real-life discussions. AI for sextingasimseo · Aug 23, 23 4:28 am
Property Search Assistance: ChatGPT aids buyers in narrowing down their search by considering preferences, budgets, and location criteria. How Can ChatGPT Help Real Estate Agents?shaikhseo · Aug 23, 23 9:15 am
Brands pay only for actual sales or conversions, making it a cost-efficient marketing model.what is affiliate marketing and how does it workasimseo · Aug 23, 23 11:51 am
Nanaimo website designers prioritize easy navigation, ensuring visitors can seamlessly explore content and services. website design nanaimoasimseo · Aug 24, 23 2:44 am
Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. best libido booster for womenshaikhseo · Aug 24, 23 11:21 am
Whether for business names, product ideas, or marketing campaigns, ChatGPT can help generate creative ideas.What is ChatGPT and how does it work?asimseo · Aug 25, 23 3:21 pm
Reddit's vibrant ecosystem of communities, discussions, and content has solidified its position as a hub for internet culture and engagement. what to do when reddit is downasimseo · Aug 26, 23 6:37 am
Clean environments contribute to the health and well-being of occupants, reducing the risk of illness and enhancing comfort. roof cleaning servicesshaikhseo · Aug 26, 23 11:35 am
By allowing users to actively shape the story's development, Beta Character AI creates a sense of agency that draws them deeper into the narrative.AI avatarsasimseo · Aug 26, 23 12:54 pm
By enabling the use of renewable energy sources, inverters contribute to reducing carbon emissions and promoting environmental sustainability. inverter battery water level indicator vent capasimseo · Aug 27, 23 8:06 am
Develop interactive training modules using ChatGPT to enhance employee onboarding and ongoing skill development. ChatGPT for Social Media Managementshaikhseo · Aug 27, 23 9:49 am
Content creators can use the plugin to brainstorm ideas, gather relevant information, and refine their writing process.Features of the Noteable Pluginasimseo · Aug 28, 23 10:30 am
If you're using an API to access ChatGPT, reaching your API usage limits may result in temporary unavailability until the limits reset. What are some ways to check if ChatGPT is down?asimseo · Aug 29, 23 8:44 am
thanks for this usefull article, waiting for this article like this again. link bokepasimseo · Aug 31, 23 5:32 am
Embedding ChatGPT into applications involves integrating the AI model's conversational capabilities directly into software, websites, or platforms. This enables seamless interactions between users and the AI, enhancing user experiences and providing valuable functionalities.Use ChatGPT Embeddingasimseo · Sep 1, 23 9:43 am
ChatGPT can deliver real-time stock market data, including prices, indices, and news. chatgpt for financeasimseo · Sep 3, 23 3:42 am
One of the strengths of GPT is its ability to transfer knowledge from the pre-training phase to various downstream tasks. This means it can be fine-tuned on specific tasks, such as text classification, translation, summarization, and more, with relatively small amounts of task-specific data. Can ChatGPT Understand Multiple Languages?asimseo · Sep 3, 23 9:01 am
ChatGPT generates contextually relevant and coherent responses, fostering engaging and authentic dialogues. How to Resolve the “Unprocessable Entity” Error in ChatGPTasimseo · Sep 4, 23 3:03 pm
Memes can provide a lighthearted way for users to engage with and reflect on their interactions with AI technology. They are a testament to the creative ways in which people incorporate AI into internet culture. Who Creates and Shares ChatGPT Memes?topservice · Sep 4, 23 11:22 pm
KOLKATA ESCORTS ESCORT KOLKATA FEMALE ESCORT SERVICE CALL GIRL NEAR ME ESCORT SERVICE AT KOLKATA CALL GIRLS PRICE KOLKATA ESCORT SERVICES KOLKATA INDEPENDENT ESCORT KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTS KOLKATA ESCORTSasimseo · Sep 5, 23 8:31 am
Individuals can access and utilize the AI Classifier for a wide range of personal and professional projects. AI text Classifiernimrashaikh · Sep 5, 23 1:49 pm
Microsoft Azure is a cloud computing platform and service offered by Microsoft. It provides a wide range of cloud-based services and solutions to help individuals and organizations build, deploy, and manage various applications and services. functionalities of Azure OpenAI Playgroundasimseo · Sep 6, 23 11:56 am
Slot machines, also known as "one-armed bandits," offer a diverse range of themes, gameplay mechanics, and potential jackpots, captivating players with their unpredictability. situs slot138asimseo · Sep 7, 23 7:21 am
InstructGPT is trained to understand and generate human-like text based on the context provided in a prompt. It can follow instructions and generate coherent and contextually relevant responses. instruct gptasimseo · Sep 8, 23 10:59 am
With the ability to analyze customer sentiment and provide personalized responses, businesses can offer an enhanced customer experience. This, in turn, can lead to increased customer loyalty and positive word-of-mouth. OpenAI Classifierasimseo · Sep 9, 23 3:08 am
Use prompts to discuss challenges, brainstorm solutions, or explore alternative perspectives.awesome chatgpt promptasimseo · Sep 9, 23 3:43 pm
This comprehensive guide explores OpenAI Integrations, highlighting its significance, key features, and how developers can leverage this powerful tool to enhance their applications with cutting-edge AI functionalities. Chat.OpenAI.comnaveedmughal · Sep 10, 23 6:41 am
Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic.video pornoasimseo · Sep 11, 23 6:53 am
Slots come in various themes, ranging from classic fruit machines to popular movies, TV shows, mythology, and more. daftar joko77asimseo · Sep 12, 23 12:46 pm
In healthcare, ChatGPT can provide information, offer symptom insights, and answer general health-related queries. How to Fix Network Error Message Appears in ChatGPTasimseo · Sep 13, 23 4:53 am
AI features a wide variety of programs across industries, including healthcare (diagnosis and treatment planning), finance (fraud recognition and algorithmic trading), autonomous cars, customer support, entertainment, and more. Open AI Playground